I disagree its rare for kids to head a ball in matches at least. Of course there was no other way for the guidance to go really, but as reported upon how do you get better without training for something and who fancies being a centre half working your way up through the youth football ranks? In fact I would argue that given teams cant train to head the ball how many coaches will train teams to whip the ball in for headers that defences are not used to dealing with? It may discourage in training but encourage in matches. It raised dilemmas perhaps for coaches in what to do with a player lets say 13, 14 that can head the ball well maybe scores a couple and keeps attempting to get his or her head on the end of corners and so on, discourage it? Sub the player off? It will create safeguarding type dilemmas of responsibility that clubs will need to address and monitor re the gradual uptake in heading and limits imposed by this guidance.
No idea why the Welsh see fit to ignore the advice or whatever reason they are not joining other Nations perhaps they all think the ball is a different shape over there! Pause for thought, I cannot imagine if this escalated to changing the game to no headers full stop! Imagine having to wait for the ball to drop before playing it. I suppose keepers would like it, or would they as it obviously affects defenders as well as attackers. All those brilliant header goals scored no more.
What about the concept of outfield players adopting some sort of protective headband...?
That would look awful but I can see the logic in this although of course I imagine its not been tested and as a society we always edge on the side of caution (so why risk it if it has no/minimal advantage) but I can see where you are coming from its been of course a part of other sports.
What about the concept of outfield players adopting some sort of protective headband...?
That would look awful but I can see the logic in this although of course I imagine its not been tested and as a society we always edge on the side of caution (so why risk it if it has no/minimal advantage) but I can see where you are coming from its been of course a part of other sports.
Indeed George, I can recall some pioneers in Cricket being pilloried for wearing protective headwear when facing some very hostile fast bowlers... attitudes change, but it can take time.
The guidance from the FA states that children aged 11 and under should no longer head the ball in training. The guidance applies to under 11 teams and below ie primary school children.
11 year olds who are playing in U12s along with all other players up to the age of u18s should see heading form a ‘low priority’ in their training but can see it gradually become more frequent as they grow older.
There is no change to the guidance on heading the ball in match situations at any age - as it is relatively infrequent for any individual player to header the ball frequently in a match, compared to a repetitive drill in training.
How much of an impact this will have on the game remains to be seen.
If you look at the evidence for heading causing dementia it is very scratchy and no serious scientist would say there is a definite link. However, it is early days with this so would you consider it ok to let your child potentially harm themselves to play a game?
The biggest study (I'm aware of) was from the Uni of Glasgow which showed a marked increase in dementia cases amongst pro footballers compared to the rest of the population. An odd result because exercise is said to decrease your chance of succumbing to dementia. The study did not state the cause of dementia was heading a football.
This may turn out like the MMR vaccine scandal or it may be true but when it comes to children why risk it?