What's the main reason why we are doing so badly?

For me the main reason is the disruption and the turmoil the club has been through. First the John Yems saga, when Kevin Betsy took over he was always being compared to John Yems. Betsy appeared unable to change things that were not working, not helped by injuries. Lewis Young tried to steady things and was succeeding, I felt he needed an experienced person alongside him if he was to take the club forward.
Now we have Mathew Etherington trying to rebuild the team. This is not something that can be achieved overnight at the moment we appear to be a mishmash of players we need continuity and a settled team.
Instead of looking for someone to blame we need to get behind Mathew and hope he can turn our fortunes around. This will take time.

Injuries and continuity.

Does anyone know what our first XI and formation should be if there was a fully fit squad who could play every game?

Galley and the owners as the main reason. Also Betsy to some extent

You do have two votes.

If we hire rooky managers (Kewell, Drummy, Yems, Young, Etherington) and we don't give them a chance to prove themselves then everybody is at fault including the supporters who screamed for change and when they got it aren't happy

It's obviously the owners they employ all these far from ideal candidates

My feeling is they employ people who will be yes men so it is nobody else's fault but yhe owners

Kewell left of his own accord. I don't recall any fans calling for Drummy to be sacked. The fans actually wanted Yems, he was doing well, Wagmi sacked him. Young was doing well, had the players playing for him, got the fans on board....Wagmi sacked him. Etherington has had 3 games, the fans aren't calling for his head, we can all see the problems are at board level. So please stop constantly blaming the fans.
Yes, most wanted Betsy out but with good reason. He was a total disaster. An academy U23 coach with no managerial experience was not what we needed. So guess what Galley/Wagmi did? They hired another one! Now we are selling our best players to our L2 relegation rivals....its not us not giving Etherington a chance to prove himself...it's Wagmi.